Ayana Sarkar, INSPIRE Fellow (Department of Physics), Shiv Nadar University, Greater Noida,
As a PhD scholar at the Shiv Nadar University (SNU) which is undoubtedly one of the best private universities in India, especially in the natural sciences, this entry to the NEP2020 does not surprise me at all and I welcome this step. Students in various institutes across India had been doing it informally for many years and this extra work was never credited on paper and also was never considered a teaching experience when applying to various jobs. Now that this teaching part is credited it’ll hopefully be a part of the transcript when a PhD student graduates and help him/her get a teaching job.
I myself have been doing credit-based teaching at the UG level for over the last 3 years. I have had the opportunity to teach freshers from engineering as well as advanced theoretical and practical courses to undergraduate students with physics major, which was a great learning experience. You never learn better than when you teach.
The TA-ship is taken very seriously at SNU by all three groups involved in this exercise that is the Faculty/Course instructor, the TA (PhD student/ advanced M.Sc students) and the students. The tutorials are also credited. For example, suppose the XYZ course has 4 credits, that is usually divided in a 3 (course)+1(tutorial) structure. So there is an evaluation and attendance part associated to the tutorial which makes the students more attentive and serious about this. From the perspective of the TA, this is a 2 (varies from department to department) credit course and is evaluated with whether the student has actually taken the TA. The duties of the TA involves solving the assignments, checking the tutorial copies, invigilation during examinations, evaluating examination copies and many a times supplement the course if the major instruction hours do not suffice. Besides this, being on campus 24/7 we are always present when a student needs guidance or doubt clearing.
TA-ships have gained popularity in NIT’s and IIT’s and a lot of my friends and colleagues from these national institutes conduct tutorials and take labs. There too these are taken very seriously. Especially in the engineering institutes, it is compulsory for all freshmen to take natural science courses especially physics and mathematics. So these classes become too large for personal guidance/doubt clearing/assignment solving and during evaluation and grading copies. So having multiple TA’s under the instructor is an absolutely necessity.
Also importantly, another thing I appreciate about SNU in this context is that a component of the salary is based on whether you have taught and completed all the duties as a TA.
The major problems I see with this scheme is related to implementation and also lot of details, seem to be missing. There are many suggestion that I have, I list some of them below. I think without these additions and elaborations, the existing policy makes no sense at all. Noting all these points I think a “holistic” approach could be taken towards TA-ships in India. Unless these things are implemented or taken care of, I can only see confusion raging among students and their respective departments.
- For those who have actually taught a class regularly in an university, we know that teaching in itself is a full time job. Now that this is on paper, the salaries of the PhD students must be increased accordingly. The PhD students were receiving 31K for research as JRF, now that they are also going to teach there must be a salary hike again. It is important that this work be awarded with money and a transcript mentioning their teaching experience. It is not enough in today’s world of competition to only be able to add this to your CV. It is extremely important that the students get proper transcripts/certificates mentioning hours of teaching and the courses they have taught. One must look at TA’s with respect as they are the future faculties and many times young faculties (Asst. Prof’s) also TA courses of older professors in universities all over the world. But unfortunately, there is no mention of an increased fellowship or a separate scholarship for the graduate students who are TA’s in this NEP 2020.
- Since the TA system is going to be implemented in all universities now, it is important that each university/college/Institute draw up their own constitution regarding the duties of a TA, their code of conduct and the relationship between the TA, the course instructor and the students. This constitution should have clear answers and provisions regarding a) the maximum number of teaching hours/week for a TA. Credits should be determined by the number of hours spent and should be discussed with the faculty instructor. This will ensure that a graduate student who is taking 5/6hours a week of advanced courses is not given the same credits as a graduate student taking elementary level courses for 1/2 hr(s) a week as the former deserves more credit, b) How the institute plans to deal with hostile work environment and sexual harassment in the workplace separately for a TA as there are competing relationships in this scenario (Faculty-TA-student) one in which the TA is the subordinate and one in which the TA is the superior, the age gap being less makes the situation more complicated, c) In order to ensure maximum learning opportunity for the TA, they should be given different courses every semester/year with a different faculty instructor. This helps the TA, come out of their comfort zones and also teaches them how to work with different mentors as the teaching and working style of each is unique, d) Instead of taking semesterly or yearly feedback from the students regarding the teaching capabilities of the TA, a monthly evaluation should be done. This will help the TA work on their shortcomings and in the long run improve student-TA relationship, e) While distributing TA’s the department must make sure that there is absolutely no gender/caste/religion/racial/sexuality bias in any of the appointments other than academic merit and proficiency of the TA. f) Above all, this constitution should clearly segregate between the duties of the TA in a course and that of a faculty as sometimes faculty instructors tend to overburden TA’s with their part of the job.
- One must also be careful whether the university is trying to do away with hiring new faculties by making the TA’s work too much and burying them with heaps of classes and evaluation sessions. This should not be the case as a full time faculty can never be replaced with student assistants. It must be mentioned that graduate TA’s should not be confused with Teaching Fellows and Graduate student Instructors (GSI’s). GSI’s or TF’s are available only in few Indian universities but is a very popular concept in foreign universities. In this case, these graduate/PhD students serve as the “primary instructor” of a course. If this is the case, such a student must be paid accordingly. Ashoka University for example, hires students as teaching fellows whose only job is taking tutorials and not research. The policy is not very clear regarding the extent or width of this scheme, so must be chalked out in details.
- Not only in teaching labs and theoretical courses, assistantships could also be provided to students in research labs by giving senior PhD students responsibility of managing instruments in larger facilities and research centres inside the institute and they could also be given the responsibility to train younger students. These TA’s would work alongside scientific assistants and gain more experience in larger facility and instrument handling. This would provide them an edge if they want a career in industry and other such large experimental facilities throughout the globe. But only a senior and expert PhD student should be given this kind of assistantship.
- Not only PhD students, this scheme should eventually be extended to meritorious and marginalised, advanced masters’ students in order to provide them with teaching experience and a fellowship for this teaching which will grant them financial independence. This is followed in SNU and in many other IIT’s/NIT’s where MS and MTech students are granted assistantships.
- I hope this is not implemented in a hurry and departments, faculties across Indian universities take the time to design courses in this manner, so that they are able to accommodate maximum number of TA’s.
- It’d be unfair if some of the students are given TA’s and some don’t get to take them. If there are too many fresh entrants compared to the courses being offered, one can give them duties in alternate semesters. This way everybody gets to have some minimum amount of teaching hours, which is the purpose of this plan.
- Also I propose that final year students be relieved of their teaching duties as they will be under immense pressure to publish and write their thesis anyway. The doctoral committees should have the power to recommend whether a particular student can be relieved of their TA duties if he/she thinks that it is becoming too much for them to manage both teaching and research. But one must however, be careful, because many a times a scholar might just be looking for a way to avoid work. At SNU, this is the standard method and we do TA’s for the first 3 years of PhD.
- Another thing which is taken care of in SNU by regular counselling session by teaching experts and senior faculties, is the relationship between the TA and the students. One thing to be noted is that the TA’s will be much closer to the age group of the students than faculties will be. This could create a number of unnecessarily complicated and sometimes unwanted situations which may affect unbiased evaluation. The TA should, from the very beginning be made aware as to how they should behave with students and that inter-personal relationships should not affect their ability to maintain an impartial classroom environment.
- The TA-ships should eventually be broadened out to one-on-one guidance for special needs and academically backward students by peers from the level of high school or middle school, as is available in many foreign countries, the models of which are being followed here. Special credits should be given to these peer tutors and some kind of a scholarship or extra grades could be provided to them. This is a good way of providing internship and teaching experience to students from a very early level.
Please write to me at ayanasster@gmail.com in case you have any questions or suggestions.

Leave a Reply